What is the Difference Between New York and Philadelphia-Style Cheesecake?

The difference between New York and Philadelphia-style cheesecake is a topic that often intrigues dessert lovers. These two popular cheesecake styles offer distinct flavors, textures, and preparation methods, setting them apart from each other. In this blog post, we’ll explore the key differences between New York and Philadelphia-style cheesecakes, including their unique characteristics, origins, and how to make each one at home.

A Brief History of Cheesecake

Before diving into the differences between New York and Philadelphia-style cheesecakes, it’s important to understand a bit about the history of cheesecake itself. Cheesecake has a long and storied history, with origins that can be traced back to ancient Greece. The Greeks made a simple cheesecake using cheese, honey, and wheat. When the Romans conquered Greece, they adopted the recipe and spread it throughout their empire. Learn more about the history of cheesecake on Wikipedia.

Cheesecake as we know it today, however, has evolved significantly from those ancient beginnings. The modern cheesecake, particularly the versions we are discussing here, is primarily an American creation, heavily influenced by European recipes but with a distinct American twist, particularly with the use of cream cheese as the main ingredient.

For those interested in further reading, you can also check out the New York Times’ article on the history of New York-style cheesecake.

The Basics of Cheesecake

At its core, cheesecake is a dessert made from a mixture of soft, fresh cheese (typically cream cheese), eggs, and sugar, poured over a crust made from crushed cookies, graham crackers, or pastry. The main difference between various styles of cheesecake lies in the type of cheese used, additional ingredients, and the method of preparation. This article from Epicurious explains more about different types of cheesecake.

What Defines New York-Style Cheesecake?

Ingredients and Flavor Profile

New York-style cheesecake is renowned for its dense, rich, and creamy texture. This is achieved by using a significant amount of cream cheese, often in combination with heavy cream or sour cream. These ingredients give the cheesecake its signature smoothness and thickness.

  • Cream Cheese: The primary ingredient that defines New York-style cheesecake is cream cheese. It gives the cheesecake its dense and creamy texture.
  • Heavy Cream or Sour Cream: These ingredients are used to add richness and creaminess to the cheesecake. The heavy cream makes the cheesecake more decadent, while sour cream adds a slight tang that balances the sweetness.
  • Eggs: Eggs are essential for binding the ingredients together and contributing to the cheesecake’s creamy texture.
  • Sugar: Adds sweetness and balances the tanginess of the cream cheese and sour cream.
  • Vanilla Extract: Vanilla is often added to enhance the flavor and add depth.

The heavy use of cream cheese and the addition of heavy cream or sour cream create a cheesecake that is exceptionally rich and dense. New York-style cheesecake is also less sweet than other varieties, allowing the tangy flavor of the cream cheese to take center stage.

Baking Technique

One of the hallmarks of New York-style cheesecake is its baking method. It is typically baked at a high temperature initially, which helps to set the crust and create a slight browning on the top. After the initial high-temperature bake, the oven temperature is lowered to cook the cheesecake slowly. This method helps to ensure that the cheesecake has a firm, dense texture without becoming dry.

Many New York-style cheesecakes are also baked using a water bath, known as a bain-marie. This technique helps to keep the cheesecake moist and prevents it from cracking on top. The water bath also ensures even cooking, giving the cheesecake its characteristic smooth texture.

Texture and Taste

The texture of New York-style cheesecake is what truly sets it apart. It is incredibly dense and creamy, with a rich mouthfeel that is almost custard-like. The flavor is tangy due to the cream cheese and sour cream, but not overly sweet. The use of high-quality vanilla extract often adds a subtle warmth and depth to the overall flavor.

New York-style cheesecake is typically served plain or with a simple fruit topping, such as strawberries or cherries. The focus is on the cheesecake itself, allowing its rich, creamy texture and tangy flavor to shine.

What Defines Philadelphia-Style Cheesecake?

Ingredients and Flavor Profile

Philadelphia-style cheesecake is often lighter and fluffier than its New York counterpart. This style of cheesecake is known for its simplicity, using fewer ingredients and often omitting the heavy cream or sour cream that is a staple in New York-style cheesecake.

  • Cream Cheese: Like New York-style, Philadelphia-style cheesecake also relies heavily on cream cheese. However, the focus is on achieving a lighter texture, so the ratio of cream cheese to other ingredients is different.
  • Eggs: Eggs are essential for giving the cheesecake structure and adding to its creaminess.
  • Sugar: Adds sweetness and enhances the flavor of the cream cheese.
  • Vanilla Extract: Vanilla is commonly used to add flavor depth, similar to New York-style cheesecake.

Unlike New York-style cheesecake, Philadelphia-style cheesecake typically does not include heavy cream or sour cream. This results in a cheesecake that is lighter and airier, with a texture that is closer to a mousse than the dense, custard-like consistency of New York-style cheesecake.

Baking Technique

The baking method for Philadelphia-style cheesecake is simpler than that of New York-style cheesecake. It is often baked at a consistent, moderate temperature, which helps to achieve a smooth and uniform texture without the need for a water bath. Because it is lighter and less dense, Philadelphia-style cheesecake does not require the same careful attention to temperature changes during baking.

Philadelphia-style cheesecake is less likely to crack during baking, thanks to its lighter texture and more forgiving baking method. This makes it a bit easier to bake, especially for beginners.

Texture and Taste

Philadelphia-style cheesecake is known for its light, airy texture. It is less dense than New York-style cheesecake, with a creamier, more delicate consistency. The flavor is also milder, with a more pronounced sweetness and a less tangy taste compared to New York-style cheesecake.

This lighter texture makes Philadelphia-style cheesecake more versatile in terms of toppings. It pairs well with a wide variety of toppings, including fresh fruit, chocolate, or whipped cream. The lighter texture also means that it can be served as part of a multi-course meal without feeling too heavy.

Origins of New York and Philadelphia-Style Cheesecakes

The Birth of New York-Style Cheesecake

New York-style cheesecake is often credited to Arnold Reuben, a German immigrant who owned a successful restaurant in New York City during the early 20th century. Reuben is said to have created the first New York-style cheesecake in the 1920s, using a recipe that emphasized cream cheese and heavy cream. His version of cheesecake quickly gained popularity and became synonymous with New York City.

The use of cream cheese as the base for New York-style cheesecake was a departure from the European-style cheesecakes that used cottage cheese or ricotta. Cream cheese, which was first developed in the United States in the late 19th century, gave the cheesecake a richer, creamier texture that became the hallmark of New York-style cheesecake.

New York-style cheesecake soon became a staple dessert in the city’s delis and diners, and its popularity spread across the country. Today, it is considered the quintessential American cheesecake, known for its indulgent texture and rich flavor.

The Philadelphia Cream Cheese Connection

Philadelphia-style cheesecake is not necessarily tied to the city of Philadelphia itself, but rather to the brand of cream cheese that has become synonymous with the style. Philadelphia Cream Cheese was first produced in the late 1800s by a dairy farmer named William Lawrence in Chester, New York. The product was marketed as a higher-quality, creamier alternative to other types of cheese available at the time.

The brand’s name, Philadelphia Cream Cheese, was chosen because Philadelphia was known for its high-quality dairy products during that era. The name stuck, and Philadelphia Cream Cheese became a household name across the United States.

Philadelphia-style cheesecake became popular in part due to the marketing success of Philadelphia Cream Cheese. The cheesecake made with this cream cheese was lighter and creamier, appealing to those who preferred a less dense dessert. Over time, this style of cheesecake became associated with the brand, leading to the term “Philadelphia-style cheesecake.”

Key Differences Between New York and Philadelphia-Style Cheesecakes

Texture and Consistency

  • New York-Style Cheesecake: Dense, rich, and creamy with a firm texture. The use of heavy cream or sour cream contributes to its thick, custard-like consistency.
  • Philadelphia-Style Cheesecake: Lighter, airier, and creamier. The omission of heavy cream or sour cream results in a texture that is closer to a mousse, with a softer and more delicate mouthfeel.

Flavor Profile

  • New York-Style Cheesecake: Tangy and rich, with a slightly sweet flavor. The tanginess of the cream cheese is balanced by the richness of the heavy cream or sour cream, creating a complex and indulgent flavor.
  • Philadelphia-Style Cheesecake: Milder and sweeter, with a more pronounced cream cheese flavor. The lighter texture allows the sweetness to come through more clearly, making it a more versatile base for various toppings.

Baking Techniques

  • New York-Style Cheesecake: Baked at a high temperature initially, then at a lower temperature to ensure density. Often baked in a water bath to prevent cracks and ensure even cooking.
  • Philadelphia-Style Cheesecake: Baked at a consistent, moderate temperature, resulting in a smoother and more uniform texture. Less likely to crack during baking, making it easier for beginners to achieve a perfect result.

How to Choose Between New York and Philadelphia-Style Cheesecake

When deciding between New York and Philadelphia-style cheesecake, consider your personal preferences:

  • If You Prefer a Rich, Decadent Dessert: New York-style cheesecake is the way to go. Its dense texture and rich flavor make it a satisfying indulgence, perfect for special occasions or when you want to treat yourself to something truly luxurious.
  • If You Prefer a Lighter, Creamier Dessert: Philadelphia-style cheesecake is ideal. Its lighter texture and milder flavor make it a versatile dessert that can be enjoyed on its own or paired with a variety of toppings.

How to Make New York-Style Cheesecake

Here’s a basic recipe for making classic New York-style cheesecake:

Ingredients

  • 2 cups graham cracker crumbs
  • 1/2 cup melted butter
  • 4 (8-ounce) packages cream cheese, softened
  • 1 1/4 cups granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup sour cream or heavy cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 4 large eggs

Instructions

  1. Preheat your oven to 325°F (163°C).
  2. Combine the graham cracker crumbs and melted butter, then press the mixture into the bottom of a springform pan.
  3. Beat the cream cheese and sugar together until smooth.
  4. Add the sour cream or heavy cream and vanilla extract, mixing well.
  5. Add the eggs one at a time, beating until just combined.
  6. Pour the filling over the crust and bake for 55-70 minutes, until the center is set.
  7. Cool the cheesecake in the oven with the door slightly open for about an hour, then refrigerate for at least 4 hours before serving.

How to Make Philadelphia-Style Cheesecake

Here’s a simple recipe for making Philadelphia-style cheesecake:

Ingredients

  • 2 cups graham cracker crumbs
  • 1/2 cup melted butter
  • 4 (8-ounce) packages cream cheese, softened
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 4 large eggs

Instructions

  1. Preheat your oven to 325°F (163°C).
  2. Combine the graham cracker crumbs and melted butter, then press the mixture into the bottom of a springform pan.
  3. Beat the cream cheese and sugar together until smooth.
  4. Add the vanilla extract and mix well.
  5. Add the eggs one at a time, beating until just combined.
  6. Pour the filling over the crust and bake for 50-60 minutes, until the center is set.
  7. Cool the cheesecake in the oven with the door slightly open for about an hour, then refrigerate for at least 4 hours before serving.

Conclusion

Understanding the difference between New York and Philadelphia-style cheesecake can help you appreciate these iconic desserts even more. Whether you prefer the rich, dense texture of New York-style cheesecake or the light, creamy consistency of Philadelphia-style cheesecake, both offer unique flavors that cater to different tastes. Now that you know the key differences, you can try making each style at home and decide for yourself which one you prefer. Whichever you choose, you’re sure to enjoy a delicious, satisfying treat!

For more on cheesecake variations, visit this guide from Food Network or check out our other articles on dessert recipes.

Leave a Comment